Gender [and] Politics

Magaret Thatcher died yesterday, provoking a lot of tweets and status updates jubilantly proclaiming “Ding Dong the witch is dead!” (or less polite words to that effect). I’m not a fan of Maggie* but I find this reaction disturbing on two levels.

Firstly, the festivity is distasteful and somewhat disproportionate. Whatever you think of her policies or her political legacy, she was an old lady – a mother and a grandmother – who died of a stroke. I’ve seen several justifications comparing this reaction to the response in Libya when Gaddafi died (or similar situations). Maggie made some very unpopular decisions but she was an elected leader in a democratic country, and she lost that position over 20 years ago. Comparing her to an incumbent dictator is frankly ridiculous and seems like an attempt to obscure a less palatable motive for the venom.

Misogyny, sexism, patriarchy. Whatever label you choose, there’s an awful lot of it about at the moment. Strong women always provoke more vitriolic reactions than strong men, even (perhaps especially) from other women. The clue is in the language: witch, bitch, cow, hag and far worse. Margaret Thatcher was the first female British Prime Minister. To date, every other PM has been white, male, able-bodied and (as far as we know) straight. Had a black, disabled or gay male PM done what she did I doubt very much we’d be seeing tweets celebrating the death of the ‘capitalist cripple’ or ‘cruel-hearted queer’. People who consider themselves to be liberal and reasonable wouldn’t start throwing around the n-word (which I’m not going to use because I don’t want this post to become about whether it’s acceptable even in the context of a discussion about language), so why are words that are offensive to women suddenly acceptable?

Feel free to hate what she did; hate what she stood for; hate the current reforms and the fact that we’re paying for her funeral, but be wary of personalising it. Margaret Thatcher was not a nice person, but neither are the the misogynists dancing on her grave.

English: Commemorative plaque, The house where...
Commemorative plaque at the house where Margaret Thatcher was born, Grantham. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

* For the record – not that my political views are relevant to this issue – I have voted Labour or Lib Dem at every election since I was 18. I would describe myself as a ‘liberal capitalist’ who believes that those who work hard should ‘do better’ (whatever that means) than those who don’t but there should be a system in place to help the vulnerable and/or unfortunate. I support gay marriage, am broadly pro-Europe and believe that the Welfare State does need reforming but some of the current cuts and changes are too extreme. I also think a 50% tax rate is counterproductive and that benefit claimants and bankers should be judged as individuals rather than being labelled as lazy or evil.

Enhanced by Zemanta

2 thoughts on “Gender [and] Politics

  1. It isn’t particularly pleasant to see people celebrating, but I understand where they’re coming from. Some of it may be misogynistic, and that’s entirely wrong, but I think the main reason that so many people are happy is because of how divisive Thatcher was.

    She destroyed communities with her policies. There are regions in South Wales among the poorest in Europe, directly related to her policy of allowing manufacturing to die, and providing nothing with which to replace it.

    As a human being she showed a complete lack of compassion, (with the possible exception of her friendship with Chilean dictator Pinochet), and championed meanness and greed.

    I’m not dancing, but I’m definitely not mourning either.

    1. Believe me I’m not mourning either! What you say about her politics is true, and if her death meant significant political change I’d understand the jubilation. However those policies either changed when she lost the leadership over twenty years ago, or have continued and will continue (subsequent governments didn’t change much back!)
      A lot of those celebrating are too young to remember life under Thatcher – it seems like an excuse for an outpouring of (mainly misogynistic) bile. Her death doesn’t upset me but the response to it does.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s